Rebuild or Die: The DTC Playbook for Chaos

From tariff shocks to Meta fatigue — how to rethink ops, creative, and media strategy to survive volatility

Author

Kent Wilson
April 13, 2025

Brought to you today by:

The chaos isn't a curveball. It's the new game.

If you’re still treating volatility like a temporary anomaly, you’re probably already behind. The last five years in the industry have been defined by seismic shifts and macro upheavals. Not normal seems to be the new normal.

So how do DTC & eCom brands survive?

This week, we dive into:

  • The latest tariff update (this might become a weekly thing)

  • What Anti-fragile brands are doing to optimize within volatility

  • How Marketing departments are rebuilding their creative stacks

  • Quick Hits (Find a new AI platform that will 100X your creator outreach)

Let’s dive in 👇

🔥 Tariff Update: What DTC Brands Need to Know (as of April 12)

  • 10% Baseline Tariff Is Active: All imports (except some exemptions) are now subject to a 10% tariff as of April 5.

  • China Imports Hit Hardest: Tariffs on Chinese goods are now 145%, with no pause or rollback. If you're sourcing from China, your margin structure just got nuked.

  • Temporary Reprieve (Except China): A 90-day pause on tariffs above the 10% base is in effect for non-China countries. Use this window to renegotiate, diversify suppliers, or reprice SKUs.

  • NEW - Electronics Exempted: Smartphones, computer parts, and certain electronics were spared — but don’t expect that logic to apply to packaging, ingredients, or raw materials.

  • Retaliation Is Real: China fired back with 125% tariffs on U.S. exports, adding more volatility to cross-border logistics and costs.

💡 TL;DR: Tariffs are here, and they're ugly — but you’ve got ~3 months (outside China) to get lean, flexible, and smart. Treat this like a warning shot, not a one-off.

🧱 The Anti-Fragile DTC Playbook

❝

The chaos isn’t a curveball. It’s the new game.

For five years running, DTC operators have been building in response to disruption—COVID, iOS14, supply shocks, interest rates.

But as Taylor Holiday puts it, the brands still standing aren’t the ones who outlasted the chaos. They’re the ones who redesigned for it.

Welcome to the anti-fragile playbook: not just weathering volatility but getting stronger from it.

📦 The real risk isn’t ad spend. It’s inventory.

Taylor breaks down eCommerce fragility into a single idea: the #1 killer of brands is overcommitted inventory.

Too much cash, committed too far into the future, with too little flexibility if forecasts shift.

Here’s how to reduce inventory fragility:

  • Shorten lead times so you're not forecasting demand months in advance.

  • Negotiate lower MOQs and better supplier terms (like Net 60/90 instead of 50/50).

  • Build supplier redundancy beyond China, which now carries the highest tariff exposure in U.S. history.

  • Sync marketing with purchasing—so your team isn’t blowing cash on a product you can’t sell fast enough.

🧮 Secret CFO: Why tariffs are not just a line item

You can’t solve this with a single percentage uplift. As The Secret CFO explains, the real impact of tariffs is circular:

  1. A tariff changes your COGS.

  2. That changes pricing, which alters demand.

  3. That changes your product mix and supply chain footprint.

  4. That may force you to change staffing or org structure.

  5. Which then loops back into cost, fulfillment, and unit margin.

“There is no top-down answer for what it all means. It has to be worked through product by product, business by business.”

This is why brands are revisiting every line in their P&L—before they even think about passing prices onto customers.

🛠 Takeaway: Assume Volatility Is Here To Stay

Anti-fragility isn’t just built in the middle of the storm. The best brands started diversifying suppliers, shortening lead times, and aligning their ops and marketing back when times were good. Not because they were paranoid, but because they were realistic.

 💡  A/B Tests Give You 2 Options. Aftersell Brands Test 6,480.

Today’s online shoppers are savvier. Your tests should be, too.

Aftersell’s new Multivariate Testing lets top Shopify brands like Obvi, HexClad, and True Classic instantly create 6,480 post-purchase offer combinations.

That means they can test their discounts, timers, shipping, and quantities…all at once.

⭐️ With multivariate offer testing, you get: 

  • Higher CVR and AOV (from the traffic you already have)

  • Ability to launch in seconds (no devs, no delays)

  • Surgically precise insights (optimize what actually works)

While other brands wait weeks for A/B test results, you’re scaling your most profitable offers by tomorrow.

🔗 See the demo and find your highest-converting offer combo in 3 hours, not 3 weeks.

🧠 How Smart Brands Are Rebuilding the Creative Stack

If you feel like your ad creative isn’t working like it used to, you’re not alone. Meta performance is more challenging than ever. But with the growth of AI, there’s an opportunity to completely redefine your creative development process.

Here’s how…

Use AI to scale ideation, not replace strategy

Jacob Posel in the podcast above shows how anyone can now generate dozens of ready-to-run ads using GPT-4’s image capabilities — with reference images and lightweight prompts.

But the real unlock isn’t the image generation itself — it’s using AI to amplify a smart creative process, not replace one.

Sarah Levinger echoed this point: Don’t just play creative roulette by prompting GPT for 20 hooks and praying one works. With AI, you may be able to spray and pray easier, but that just means you’ll drown in a river of mediocre creative.

Instead, she recommends using identity-based prompting to make your copy resonate with the customer’s sense of self (not just product features).

She even gave a killer ChatGPT prompt for it:

𝗣𝗿𝗼𝗺𝗽𝘁: 𝗜𝗱𝗲𝗻𝘁𝗶𝘁𝘆-𝗕𝗮𝘀𝗲𝗱 𝗔𝗱 𝗖𝗼𝗽𝘆 𝘄𝗶𝘁𝗵 𝗥𝗲𝗹𝗮𝘁𝗮𝗯𝗹𝗲 𝗧𝗼𝗻𝗲 𝗢𝗽𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻𝘀

You’re a world-class copywriter trained in identity marketing and behavioral psychology. You specialize in writing ad copy that helps customers see themselves in the product—and feel good about it. 𝗬𝗼𝘂𝗿 𝗷𝗼𝗯: Flip product-first messaging into customer identity-first headlines that feel authentic, punchy, and platform-ready.

 This is just a sample☝️

⛏️ Mine organic gold, not just paid winners

Joe Marston recently laid out a smarter framework for ad ideation: Look at what’s already going viral on TikTok before jumping into paid.

Search for videos tied to your product’s core benefit (e.g., “hydration hack” for electrolyte brands).

Then sort by:

  • Views

  • Comments

  • Watch-through rate

But don’t just copy — study the format. Is it a first-person story? A POV skit? A breakdown at the grocery store?

Then, rebuild the structure around your own offer. That’s how Joe’s team turned a viral hook into a 7-figure ad with 3X ROAS in just 7 days.

✅ Takeaway: Find Ways To Both Increase And Improve your Creative

Don’t just leverage AI and social channels to test more. Instead, source better inputs, build faster feedback loops, and plug creative ops into brand strategy.

Quick Hits

Reply

or to participate.